In a previous post, we recommended adding paper or cardboard to a compost heap that’s too moist. Paper will absorb water as well as provide short-term air space to aide in circulation if it’s crumpled. That suggestion, as pointed out by one of our more careful readers, brought up an entirely different subject: is composting paper safe? The answer is yes. And no.
Paper — made from wood pulp — seems a likely addition to compost because of its source: nature. Newspapers have long been held as a good source of “brown” component in the brown-green, carbon-nitrogen balance that compost piles need (so much so that adding too much paper will tip the balance). But paper might also contain some harmful ingredients in the form of inks, dyes and other treatments.
FREE SHIPPING!
Convert kitchen, yard and garden waste into soil-nourishing organic matter with our backyard tested composting bins and supplies. Decreasing household waste and building your soil has never been so easy!
These days, most newspaper inks are soy-based, a good thing for the environment (though the soy used in inks is likely from GMO sources). But some inks may still contain petro-chemicals or pigments if they include color as most papers do. Also newsprint may hold some chlorine from the bleaching process. Newspaper is bleached less than most commercial office papers but may still contain some chlorine. This is a good reason not to compost office paper, mail or magazines. Slick papers of the sort used by magazines are also treated with petro-chemicals, so that they won’t yellow and break down as quickly as newsprint. The best idea is to recycle all white, slick or otherwise treated papers.
But newspapers? Apparently the jury is still out. The Sierra Club’s Mr. Green says there’s a study that newsprint contains less toxic material than straw or grass and is therefore safe to use. He doesn’t cite the study and though we found many references to Mr. Green’s claim, we couldn’t find a study that directly addresses his statement (readers, can you help?). It’s well known that grasses and straw treated with herbicides and other sprays aren’t healthy additions to compost and may even kill some plants (organic farms, lawns, and gardens mean clean grass and straw going into compost). Some composters dismiss the small risk of adding toxins to the pile by including newspaper, arguing that the microorganisms that facilitate the composting process also help break down the toxins. Cornell University’s compost page suggests that the risk of using even glossy paper are minimal. Over at City Food Growers, there’s a good accounting of the risks of using paper in you compost and garden and suggest there’s an easy solution…recycle! There are plenty of things to keep your compost heaps, well, heaping. If you do use newsprint, be sure it’s shredded. If not, it may still be in you pile a year later, impeding good circulation of air and moisture.
A note on cardboard: Modern brown, corrugated cardboard uses neither coloring or glues and is okay to use in compost (or as mulch). Just be sure it’s shredded. White or colored cardboard? Again, some say the risks are small. Personally, your conscientious Planet Natural Blogger wouldn’t use them.
Recommended Products
Compost Maker
A proprietary blend of microorganisms used to break down kitchen and yard waste.
SoilSaver Composter
Efficient and affordable, SoilSaver features an award-winning design.
Compost Turner
An easy and effective way to mix and add oxygen to the pile without heavy lifting.
Copyright © 2004-2017
13 Responses to “Composting Paper”
Leaves, straw, coffee grounds and tea bags, grass clippings, fall leaves, animal manures (cow, horse, pig, chicken) do not use cat or dog droppings, fruit rinds-skins-pits, newspaper and cardboard, ashes from the fireplace and dryer lint. Pretty much anything that consists of organic compounds. But don’t use meat products because they lure in unwanted pests. Just remember to keep the compost pile moist and turn using a pitch fork on a regular basis so oxygen can reach the middle of the pile and allow the decomposition to keep happening.
People scare other people away from composting. Perhaps if you are on limited space and need to use the compost faster some of these ideas may be necessary but I have composted for years. I started off using 4×4 skids that I salvaged free. I nailed 3 sides together and put the 4th on hinges so I could swing it wide open. I put everything in my compost. The bedding and manure from my chicken coup, all scraps including eggshells (and I dont rinse them) coffee grounds, old garden plants, leaves and grass clippings, even weeds from weeding the flower beds. The heat kills the seeds.
I dont turn it… I just let it sit and sit. Although sometimes the chickens are in there scratching and picking through the newest scraps or for the biggest juicy worms. I dont water it… nature does that…its called rain. I built a 2nd one and when that gets full I start the 2nd. when I need compost, I go to the oldest one and remove from the bottom. This is not rocket science. My PH is always fine maybe slightly acidic which most plants love. If I am planting something that needs a more alkaline ph… I had a bit of lime. I dust plants with lime to keep bugs away naturally so I usually want it slightly acid knowing I am adding lime to dust in.
you can bury meats and other items that you don’t necessarily want to have sit in a compost pile making it gross. My mom buried everything for 10 years at a house we lived in and by the end of that time the garden soil was black and rich. I prefer the multiple bin route that the 2nd commenter here uses because I’m container gardening now and burying things is a big hassle.
I’m interested in composting, so I’ll give a try using only the smallest pail.. to serve as pot when the compost aged.
At one point the article states to not recycle office paper due to chlorine, and then the very next line states that it’s best to recycle office paper. I think the first “recycle” was meant to read “compost”.
Nice catch Jack! Thanks for pointing it out!
Seems to me that any tiny trace of chlorine released in the compost pile would be immediately converted to sodium chloride or calcium chloride or magnesium chloride etc… by combining with these elements. Those are just simple and harmless salts in absolutely miniscule quantities. A total non-issue, apparently.
I enjoy composting “made” items into soil, returning them all to the good earth. When our daughter was teaching gardening to high school and middle school students she was proud to tell them about her parents composting old and worn out clothing. They wondered about that until she explained that cotton and wool decomposed slowly eventually becoming soil. No sense wasting ratty robes, blue jeans, t-shirts and even underwear (cut off the spandex because there is miles of that stuff in waistbands). We also compost bits of meat and fat and also bones despite what naysayers insist. Bury them deep or put them in the bottom of a new compost pile. They will decompose. In forty years we have never had a bug or rodent problem.
Another means of composting in a way is when making new garden bed. Instead of digging out grass we put layers of old cotton sheets over the grass and putting garden soil over the sheets. The sheets and grass will compost by the time planting season arrives and the soil will be friable. It works.
Cardboard we use for temporary paths. It takes months for it to decompose. Eventually we cover those paths with fir bark chips.
Life is good.
Love the “Life is good” at the end.
Hi in Bangkok l have a planter box garden about the size of two coffins. ln the middle is compost section about the size of a bar fridge. Its full of big Asian worms.
I had a lot of office paper to throw out and l was afraid of the chemicals so l soaked it in water for a few days – rinsing off every now and then. I’ll put it in bit by bit.
Regards Al
Are worms hurt by rotating compost bins?
I don’t know for sure, but I’m sure a couple are injured or killed in the process, but turning improves the health of your pile and the availability of bacteria for the worms to eat – probably a net gain for the worm colony.
As I’m very limited on space i use a small compost tumbler and 2 static bins. I add egg cartons, office paper and any none shiny and not too colorful newspapers/junkmail. Like most I have way more green than browns available here in the outer suburbs. Most of my brown content is paper, garden trimmings and stored leaves from Autumn/Fall.
I keep the fresh compostables rolling in the tumbler until it loses most of it’s heat then place it in a static bin that needs filling making room for the next tumbler batch. The static bins are aerated daily (when I remember) with one of those spiral aerators. Works beautifully in the warmer months but very little production in winter.
Thanks for some good information and whatever it is you do – Do the best you can!